Tuesday, January 18, 2005
Production and Overproduction
* A big part of the problem is the way that academic institutions think about and measure productivity. It’s become increasingly common for state legislatures to hammer public institutions for more and more quantitative evidence of productivity, but even at institutions which do not have to answer to legislators, various metrics of productivity have become more and more common.
* What ends up being measured, however? First, the productivity of scholarship: numbers of things published and disseminated, grant monies secured, quantities of fellowships and memberships. In suggesting that the status quo of such productivity lacks (and needs) dignity, John Holbo is pointing to the core of some of academia’s worst ills. The drive to scholarly overproduction which now reaches even the least selective institutions and touches every corner and niche of academia is a key underlying source of the degradation of the entire scholarly enterprise. It produces repetition. It encourages obscurantism. It forces overspecialization as a strategy for controlling the domains to which one is responsible as a scholar and teacher.
* You can’t blame anyone in particular for this. Everyone is doing the simple thing, the required thing, when they publish the same chapter from an upcoming manuscript in six different journals, when they go out on the conference circuit, when they churn out iterations of the same project in five different manuscripts over ten years. None of that takes conscious effort: it’s just being swept along by an irresistible tide. It’s the result of a rigged market: it’s as if some gigantic institutional machinery has placed an order for scholarship by the truckload regardless of whether it’s wanted or needed. It’s like the world’s worst Five-Year Plan ever: a mountain of gaskets without any machines to place them in.
* You could try to contest this if you wanted to measure academic productivity by looking to the importance or significance of particular scholarly work. But even that inevitably will lead to some ghastly results, whether you use a citation index or Google Scholar.
* So my simple suggestion is this: stop. Administrations and faculties need to stop caring how much someone writes or publishes or says, or even how important what they’ve published is according to some measurable or quantifiable metric. Not only because trying to measure productivity in terms of scholarship destroys scholarship, but because it detracts from the truly important kind of productivity in an academic institution.
* What really matters is this: how different are your students when they graduate from what they would have been had they not attended your institution, and how clearly can you attribute that difference to the things that you actively do in your classrooms and your institution as a whole? What, in short, did you teach them that they would not have otherwise known? How did you change them as people in a way that has some positive connection to their later lives?
* It’s the only productivity that matters, however we try to measure or account for it. What do we do by design that we can reasonably say produces a positive, identifiable difference in the lives of our students and our wider community? Scholarship enters that question somewhere, but hardly at all in the ghastly spew of excess publication that contemporary academia demands.
s p a c i n g : : : whose space is public space?
Disc Withdrawal
Monday, January 17, 2005
Bloody Sundays - PittsburghLIVE.com
Wednesday, January 12, 2005
Research :: itbusiness.ca
Most enterprises customers, however, will likely take the same approach to market research as they have to establishing vendor partners: they'll winnow them down as much as possible, and in many cases will seek out those with the broadest portfolio of expertise. That doesn't mean there isn't any room for differentiation. I tend to see IDC, for example, as the best place to find overall market statistics on IT spending, including hardware and software sales. Gartner seems better at assessing industry trends like utility computing. Forrester, meanwhile, has some highly sophisticated practices aroundWell. I have no comment. None. Nada. Rien. Let's the facts stand. Yep. No idea what he could mean by "No obvious replacements." That's crazy talk. As Bill the Cat would say, "Cough. Oop Ack."
specific vertical markets like finance. All of them offer everything, but each has subjects in which they stand out. More than most industries, analyst firms are truly a product of their employees.
Nurturing those employees and maintaining morale may be the most important element in the integration process at Gartner and Meta, which probably ruffled feathers when they said their merger
is intended to achieve "operational efficiencies" -- you don't have to be an analyst to know what that means. Even at IDC Canada, which so far has stayed away from acquisition activity, several long-standing analysts have fled, with no obvious replacements. These are people, after all, who are used to assessing the future. In the short-term, the forecast doesn't look good.
Monday, January 10, 2005
Googling Malcolm Gladwell :: Better Living Centre
How to Take Down a Christmas Tree :: Bow. James Bow
Wednesday, January 05, 2005
Recently Read:: Lorraine Adam's Harbor
The characters:
He and his friends go clubbing in shoplifted suits, fall in love, try to figure out American body language and slang and often get it wrong. They get fake papers, commit minor insurance fraud, live on the edge, always terrified of the authorities. Adams draws her characters with compassion and humor, taking us inside their heads by means of an invented idiom crafted from her protagonists' fractured English and fluid Arabic cadences, at once poetic and deliberately ungainly: "But Rafik this early was asleep," Aziz thinks. Or "the acrid of bus bellied up to them."A review by a Muslim blog
List of reviews:
Oh - I did reach someone in Calgary. But, no, they've gone home for the day.
Tuesday, January 04, 2005
Requiem for a Cop :: Dana Stevens
Monday, January 03, 2005
Flit on DART
Anyway, worth reading. The nut graf is here:
Starting with the McCallum years, we officially became "hotspot" averse. (Regarding strategic airlift, his now famous line was "No one has yet been able to give me a single instance where the absence of this capability stopped us or significantly delayed us moving people or equipment from point A to point B." Well, we've got a single instance now.)
Unfortunately, as was commented on at the time, that mentality makes it now effectively impossible to deploy in natural disaster scenarios, as well. DART, an Eggleton "first-in" project, has atrophied to the point where it proved undeployable even to Haiti during the hurricanes last year. If all this makes you wonder how effective the CF might be if that earthquake had been off of Vancouver Island, instead of Aceh, well, you probably should wonder. It's certainly not encouraging. Hopefully the Americans will have an aircraft carrier free then, too.
The good people of Port Alberni might want to flinch.
If I have time, I might skim through the army.ca forums to see what the people who actually know think.Similarly, I liked Paul Wells' evisceration of the media's fixation of cdn cabinet meetings as a viable response to this tragedy. I mean, do you really think that Joe Comuzzi is going to help the Sri Lankans? Will Liza Frulla want to defer this to the relevant Quebec minister (actually, given that Alberta, BC and Ontario have all beaten the feds to the mark - don't answer that)? Can Stephane Dion pen a stiffly worded missive to Mother Nature, reminding her of her statutory duties? Does this mean that Judy Sgro will now have Thai strippers working in her office and on her re-election campaign instead of Romanians? Can Ken Dryden get his Dad to send more sleeping kits?
Seriously, I realize that Blackberries are banned in Cabinet meetings - but one would think that they are still used outside the Langevin Block. Face to face meetings weren't and aren't necessary in this case.